In Greeley, Colorado, the immigration policies of former President Donald Trump have sparked mixed reactions among voters in a closely-watched congressional district. Miranda Niedermeier, a 35-year-old resident, shares the initial sentiment of many Trump supporters who favor immigration control, especially measures aimed at apprehending undocumented immigrants with criminal records. However, her support wanes significantly in light of recent developments, particularly the federal immigration raids carried out in Minneapolis that resulted in the deaths of two American citizens.
"At first, the focus was on criminals, but now authorities seem to use even minor traffic violations as a pretext for deportation," Niedermeier observed. She voiced strong disapproval of what she perceives as a departure from humane enforcement practices, emphasizing that the government’s approach lacks compassion. "This situation shouldn't be life or death. We aren’t a third-world country. What on earth is happening?" she questioned.
The ongoing immigration crackdown in Minnesota, which has persisted for over a month, resonates deeply within the diverse communities of Colorado’s 8th Congressional District. Spanning northeast from Denver and encompassing agricultural workers, oil and gas drilling crews, and retail centers, the district reflects nationwide tensions surrounding immigration enforcement. The situation has prompted some voters to reinforce their political stance, while others are reassessing their positions ahead of upcoming elections.
Edgar Cautle, a 30-year-old Mexican-American oil field worker and Trump supporter, called for moderation in immigration policy. His concerns stem from distressing images of immigration officials detaining children and separating families. "Such actions are alienating people," he stated, suggesting that these enforcement tactics may diminish support for the former president.
Republican Congressman Gabe Evans, representing the district since his narrow 2024 election win, advocates for immigration enforcement concentrated on criminals rather than law-abiding undocumented residents. With a background as a police officer and personal ties to the Mexican-American community through his mother, Evans supports prioritizing the removal of dangerous individuals—"criminals, not grandmothers," as he phrased it.
Evans expressed unease about Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) procedures reportedly allowing entry into homes based on administrative orders without judicial oversight. He plans to examine these practices at an upcoming House hearing involving Department of Homeland Security officials. Despite his concerns about enforcement overreach, Evans assigned accountability for the current divide to Democratic politicians, alleging they exploit immigration for political gain ahead of the November elections. He noted that ICE operations in his district target specific criminal cases rather than the numerous local industries that depend on immigrant labor, such as meatpacking plants and dairies.
The demographic makeup of Evans’ district includes nearly 40% Hispanic voters. Interviews with over twenty Hispanic constituents revealed widespread offense at the intensified immigration raids, with many U.S. citizen respondents expressing fear about their own safety. Jennifer Hernandez, 30, voiced anxiety about potential targeting based on her surname or appearance while shopping in Brighton, Colorado.
Conversely, some voters continue to endorse enforcement actions despite the fatalities. Herb Smith, a 61-year-old black generator installer and Trump voter, underscored the need to address immigration issues firmly. Having formerly resided in Minneapolis, he expressed hostility toward Somali immigrants whom President Trump has criticized.
Dominic Morrison, a 39-year-old telecommunications technician, conveyed disapproval of life-threatening enforcement outcomes but acknowledged the importance of respecting immigration laws. "I understand everyone wants a better life, but entering a country without authorization is not well-regarded," he remarked.
Democratic leaders in the district have condemned the rise in immigration raids, attributing the escalation to Congressman Evans’ unwavering support of Trump. Jim Getman, a retired electrician who volunteered for Democrats in 2024, criticized Evans for refraining from opposing policies he views as harmful.
Joe Hernandez, a 27-year-old forklift operator from Commerce City, discussed the heightened caution exercised by immigrant families due to fears of racial profiling and immigration detention. He and his siblings, all U.S.-born citizens, have contemplated relocating to family property in Mexico for safety reasons. Previously disengaged from the voting process, Hernandez intends to participate in upcoming elections, noting a growing recognition of the importance of political involvement among his peers.